Archive for the ‘Editorial’ Category

Pantomime villains

Monday, March 16th, 2009

At the moment, I’m working my way through Xam’d: Lost Memories. It feels like an excellent series, but it’s hard to pin down exactly why that is. There is no single element that innately attracts my attention, it just feels special; the kind of series that represents most of what is good about anime.

Looking a bit closer and comparing it to something like Code Geass, the immediate difference is in the character design. The design of characters like Charles and Schneizel, Lelouch and Kallen, are archetypal. Charles looks exactly like the kind of loud mouthed and blood-thirsty emperor he is. Watching them could almost be likened to a pantomime experience, because, when you’ve seen so much anime, you know exactly what to expect when a character like Lelouch appears, with elements of his archetype foreshadowed years before by Death Note’s Light.

However, the character designs used in Xam’d are ambiguous and realistic. There are no huge, flashing lights hanging over a villain’s head, hinting that “THIS PERSON IS EVIL”. Furuichi is a good example, a caring friend transformed into something darker, worsening with every new episode; he is multi-layered, conflicted; human. Perhaps Xam’d feels so immersive precisely because it is so ambiguous and unpredictable? One hangs on every word because there is no telling where it may all lead?

Generic anime

Thursday, March 12th, 2009

In the previous post, I wrote that Toradora! was generic, but that’s not necessarily such a bad thing, just as long as you admire the genre in question. In the case of Toradora!, it’s a high-school romance, and my problem is, I’m not in college any more and I have nothing in common with the characters. What am I supposed to get from it? It’s a genre that means nothing to me.

At the same time, I’m watching an anime series from 2006 called Bartender. It’s an episodic, slice of life drama that examines the lives of the adults who regularly visit the ‘Eden Hall’ bar. Sometimes it’s romantic, other times it’s tragic, but most of all, it just makes me want to drink alcohol!

There is no way that the lover of a series like Toradora! would watch Bartender. As far as I can tell, the average viewer of anime is a teenager, and just as I couldn’t care less about some typical high-school romance, I wouldn’t expect the teenager to understand much of anything about the appeal of the adult world in Bartender, either.

I really think that one of the biggest problems with anime is that it is so age restrictive. So many fans get older and fall into apathy because they have grown out of it. I could have loved Toradora! five years ago.

Toraboring

Tuesday, March 10th, 2009

Toradora! is one of the few anime series I’ve managed to keep pace with over the sparse winter months. It’s been entertaining enough and nicely animated, but the truth is, I’ve long since lost interest in the characters. Without any particular turning point, I just stopped caring about them.

By now it’s clear that Toradora! is a teenage romance anime, but during those opening couple of story arcs, it seemed much more illusive. Characters like Minori and Ami were troubled, not just by love, but by life itself. The series was interesting and philosophical, and didn’t seem to be as geared towards being the kind of melodramatic twister it has now become.

I don’t care about Ryuuji’s love life, or whether he ends up with Taiga or Minori, that’s not why I’m watching. I liked that the first half was introspective and ambiguous, one particular moment I’m thinking of is Minori’s lonely heart-to-heart with Ryuuji, the way that scene, under the starry night, seemed so introspective and dark, yet this whole sense of mystery and insecurity has quietly transformed into terrible cuteness, embarrassing Christmas songs and unlikely plot twists. Hence, the comparisons to Honey & Clover strike me as way off the mark, too. Honey & Clover had an adult cast and was about more than just romance; Toradora! aspires to reach those same heights, but it falls short.

It is generic, unfortunately.